$950K fine leads to dispute over North Dakota agency jurisdiction

Most people, when they consider some issue worthy of bringing a lawsuit, assume they will have "their day in court." For some matters, this is true. Arrested for a drunk driving offense, you will go to court. Want to sue your neighbor for $100,000 in damage they caused to your home? That too, is a matter for which a North Dakota court would have jurisdiction.

And from the North Dakota district courts, an appeal could be to the state's Court of Appeal, which is made up of judges from the district courts temporarily assigned to that court. The state's Supreme Court is responsible for assigning cases to the Court of Appeal and some years may not assign any cases. There are also municipal courts, which typically hear cases involving municipal ordinance violations.

But a whole range of matters is adjudicated by the administrative bodies of the State's agencies. Agency law governs a wide variety of matters, ranging from Game and Fish Department and the Highway Patrol to the Wheat Commission and the State Real Estate Commission.

But sometimes knowing which state agency is the relevant one may be somewhat difficult. A case involving a trucking company and the state Industrial Commission over the dumping of wastewater from oil drilling has led to such a jurisdictional dispute.

The Department of Health settled with the trucking company for the violation with a $200,000 fine and a suspended fine of $259,000. The Industrial Commission has disagreed with an Administrative Law Judge who ruled they lacked jurisdiction over the matter and levied a fine of $950,000.

The Department of Mineral Resources agrees that Industrial Commission is the proper authority, and the Director worries that the ALJ's ruling would allow "agency shopping" to find the entity that would accept the lowest fine.

Given the size of the fine, the IC expects the case to be appealed to the district court and from there to the Supreme Court, which will have the final word on which agency has jurisdiction.

Source: thedickinsonpress.com, "N.D. regulators stick with $950,000 fine for saltwater dumping, expect appeal to district court," Mike Nowatzki, April 20, 2016

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Do You Need Legal Help?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Firm Information

Brudvik Law Office

Mayville Office
231 9th Avenue SE
P.O. Box 547
Mayville, ND 58257

Phone: 701-786-6177
Fax: 701-788-4243
Mayville Law Office Map

West Fargo Office
730 13th Ave E
West Fargo, ND 58078

Phone: 701-786-6177
Fax: 701-788-4243
West Fargo Law Office Map

Finley Office
300 Central Avenue
Finley, ND 58230

Phone: 701-786-6177
Fax: 701-788-4243
Map & Directions

Hillsboro Office
1 N Main Street
P.O. Box 847
Hillsboro, ND 58045

Phone: 701-786-6177
Fax: 701-788-4243
Map & Directions

Grand Forks Office
2810 19th Ave S
Grand Forks, ND 58201

Phone: 701-786-6177
Fax: 701-788-4243
Map & Directions

Chandler Office
3185 S Price Rd
Suite 7
Chandler, AZ 85248

Phone: 480-374-1651
Fax: 701-788-4243
Map & Directions

Grafton Office
640 Hill Ave
Grafton, ND 58237

Phone: 701-786-6177
Fax: 701-788-4243
Map & Directions

Fargo Office
203 8th Street S.
Fargo, ND 58103

Phone: 701-786-6177
Fax: 701-788-4243
Map & Directions

East Grand Forks Office
308 Demers Ave
P.O. Box 4
East Grand Forks, MN 56721

Phone: 218-773-6841
Fax: 218-773-2845
Map & Directions